Spaceflight & Missions

Vulcan failure probe zeroes in on inadequate fuel flow to booster engines

United Launch Alliance said Wednesday that its preliminary analysis of Vulcan flight data points to a fuel-supply problem, not an engine fault, as the reason the rocket fell short of orbit Sunday with 40 Amazon Leo satellites aboard. The finding is not a final cause, but it shifts attention away from the Blue Origin-built BE-4 engines that power Vulcan’s first stage.

ULA posted the update at 11 a.m. EST (1600 UTC). The company said low booster thrust appeared to result from inadequate fuel delivery from the vehicle to the two methane-fueled BE-4s, rather than from how the engines performed. ULA did not say which component failed to deliver enough fuel or why, and it cautioned that the investigation is at an early stage and that it wants to avoid speculation.

What happened on Sunday

Vulcan lifted off at 12:40 p.m. EST (1740 UTC) Sunday from Space Launch Complex 41 at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station. It was the rocket’s fifth flight and its first since February.

ULA said the vehicle showed low first-stage performance just after liftoff. Stage separation then occurred at low altitude and below the velocity needed to reach orbit. The company lost telemetry about 10 minutes into the flight, ending any chance of completing the mission. That matches what Spaceflight Now observed during the webcast: the BE-4s appeared to burn longer than the prelaunch timeline called for, and the first stage separated from the Centaur later than expected.

ULA President and CEO Mark Peller said Tuesday that the Centaur upper stage separated and ignited its RL10 engines. The first stage, however, left it in too low an energy state for the Centaur to make up the deficit.

Solid boosters and BE-4 cleared, for now

The six Northrop Grumman GEM 63XL solid rocket boosters were the main concern going into the flight. One suffered a nozzle malfunction on Vulcan’s second flight in October 2024. Another appeared to have a nozzle burn-through on the USSF-87 mission Feb. 12. Vulcan reached its planned orbit both times, but the Space Force suspended national security launches on the rocket after the February anomaly. ULA said the boosters performed nominally Sunday, following nozzle improvements, and burned out and separated about 1 minute 35 seconds after liftoff.

The flight was also the first for the BE-4 since a New Glenn rocket exploded during a test May 28, heavily damaging Blue Origin’s Launch Complex 36. Blue Origin CEO Dave Limp later said that failure began at the main oxygen valve on one of New Glenn’s seven BE-4s. The two engines on Vulcan, rated together at more than 1 million pounds of thrust, carried a retrofit designed and tested after that explosion. Bloomberg reported this month, citing a memo from Limp, that Blue Origin is targeting January for New Glenn’s return to flight. A Blue Origin filing with the Federal Communications Commission lists a Jan. 15 to April 15 window.

The preliminary findings also leave intact the record of the Centaur 5, which has flown only on Vulcan. NASA said last month that it is pursuing two upper-stage options for the Space Launch System on Artemis 4: its current interim cryogenic propulsion stage and a stretched Centaur 5.

Customers wait as Vulcan is grounded

Vulcan has no return-to-flight date. The Federal Aviation Administration will oversee the ULA-led investigation, take part in every step and approve the final report, including corrective actions.

The Space Force, which had hoped to use Vulcan for national security payloads, is waiting. So is Amazon, which bought 38 Vulcan launches for its Leo internet constellation. The lost batch was Amazon’s largest to date. A successful launch would have raised its Leo total to 436 satellites, against a planned first-generation constellation of more than 3,200. SpaceX has launched more than 11,200 Starlink satellites since 2019. With Vulcan and New Glenn both grounded, Amazon’s remaining launches are on Arianespace’s Ariane 6 and SpaceX’s Falcon 9.

The loss is ULA’s first outright mission failure since Boeing and Lockheed Martin formed the company in 2006. Three of Vulcan’s five flights have now had problems, though Sunday’s is the only one in which the payload failed to reach orbit. ULA said it will provide further updates as the investigation continues.

Source: spaceflightnow.com

Related Articles

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Back to top button