JPL marks 90 years with a lingering question: who owns the lab?

Of NASA’s research centers, only the Jet Propulsion Laboratory is run under contract by a university, and that arrangement has shaped both its culture and its recurring disputes over who controls it. Historian Peter Westwick, whose book on JPL covers the years 1976 to 2004, laid out the origins and tensions of the relationship in a conversation with Casey Dreier.
A contractor-run center inside NASA
JPL is a federally funded research and development center (FFRDC), a category once known as government-owned, contractor-operated, or GOCO. Westwick noted that the model is not unusual in government. The national laboratories that grew out of the Atomic Energy Commission, later under the Department of Energy, include Los Alamos, Livermore, Berkeley, Oak Ridge, Brookhaven and Argonne, all run by contractors rather than the federal government. Within NASA, however, JPL is the exception.
The agency’s other centers descend from a network of laboratories it inherited from the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics (NACA). JPL came from a different place. NASA wanted the lab’s expertise in guidance, control and radio telemetry, developed through its rocket work for the Army, because automated spacecraft would need to be tracked and commanded. With rocket development shifting to industry, Westwick said, JPL and Caltech were open to the move, and NASA took over the lab wholesale.
Whose JPL?
Westwick described the arrangement as a three-body problem linking JPL, Caltech and NASA. Caltech employs all JPL staff and receives an annual management fee plus overhead from NASA, which also pays for the lab’s hardware. Westwick said the structure helps recruitment through Caltech’s prestige, and in theory gives JPL room to work without constant NASA oversight. Distance from Washington adds to that independence.
Each side, he said, considers JPL its own: NASA because it funds the lab, Caltech because it holds the contract. Caltech has been the lab’s only operator since its founding, a position Westwick said is now being questioned.
Scale complicates matters. JPL’s workforce, which he put at roughly 4,000 to 6,000 depending on the period, far exceeds Caltech’s. From the 1970s through the 1990s, Westwick said, the fee and overhead together amounted to about 15% of the campus budget, equivalent to about $100,000 per professor. That made it difficult for administrators to entertain faculty objections to running a large off-campus laboratory.
Caltech’s contribution is scientific as well as administrative. Westwick pointed to Bruce Murray, who led the camera team on several Mariner missions before becoming JPL director, and Ed Stone, a Caltech professor who served as lead scientist on Voyager. The campus is about a 15-minute drive from the lab, which makes collaboration practical.
Systems engineering and the 1970s squeeze
Westwick traced JPL’s identity as a planetary center to lessons from its early Moon missions. Its Army rocket work had allowed repeated test firings at White Sands Missile Range. Spacecraft offered only one attempt. After failures among the Ranger probes, JPL faced sharp criticism from Congress and NASA, and responded with the rigor of systems engineering.
That discipline, Westwick said, produced a culture of exacting design reviews and punishing work schedules when launch windows approached, and became the basis of the lab’s later successes.
The mid-1970s brought a reversal. Even as Voyager returned images and data from Jupiter and Saturn, NASA was reprioritizing and threatening deep cuts to JPL’s budget and to follow-on missions. Westwick said some people went so far as to ask whether the lab was surplus to NASA’s needs and could be closed. Bruce Murray called the downturn “the bathtub.”
Source: www.planetary.org




